AsiaTEFL Logo        The Journal of AsiaTEFL
   
The Journal of AsiaTEFL
Articles By Subject
Current Issue
Past Issues
Special Issue
Information of the Journal
Editorial Board
Submission Guidelines
Ethical Guidelines
Manuscript Submission
Journal Order
User Information
Search
Today 373
Total 505,047
Current Issue
Go List

Volume 5 Number 3, Autumn 2008, Pages 1-223   


PDF Download
   

'China English': Facts, Fantasies, and Fallacies

    Changyin Li


Does 쁂hina English'? a Chinese variety of English ? exist? This question has been a topic of much debate for more than two decades among Chinese scholars and teachers of English. At the moment, the advocates of 쁂hina English' seem to be winning, as their position caters to Chinese patriotic feelings, e.g. we can do anything, including nativizing a foreign language, and their opponents have failed to present solid proof. This paper argues that 쁂hina English' is totally self-proclaimed, neither meeting international standards nor acknowledged by native-speaking experts of English, and that the supporters have ignored the sociolinguistic history of the language. After examining English in China by three sets of different but similar international standards for the recognition of a new variety of English, it concludes that the so-called 쁂hina English' is not a reality yet. Nor will it be or should it be.

Keywords: China English, facts, fantasies, fallacies